Skip to main content
3 minutes reading time (664 words)

The Cost of Knowledge: Why Visibility isn’t Enough

cost_knowledg_20261022-063627_1
In a thought piece in The European Journal of Development Research, Kate Meagher asks the question: When we try to make knowledge fairer, should we reject the tools handed down by dominant institutions, or repurpose them?

Her answer is to repurpose. This way, knowledge becomes less Eurocentric, she argues, by adapting ideas from North and South alike to local needs. 

Open Science faces its own version of this question, with this year's Open Access Week theme, "The Cost of Knowledge", putting it in focus. The harder questions that we must address now are who pays for knowledge, and who benefits. 

Visibility is not the same as power

Meagher draws on a distinction from the philosopher Nancy Fraser. Recognition is about whose knowledge is valued, while redistribution is about the material structures, such as sources, institutions, infrastructure, that decide who can produce knowledge in the first place. For Fraser, fairness needs recognition and redistribution together, arguing that if nothing changes in who holds the money and the tools, inequality stays, or even grows. 

Open Access, but who pays?

Open Access has made millions of papers free to read, which is undoubtedly a real gain in recognition. However, openness funded through article processing charges, transfers solely the cost from readers to authors.

Researchers at well-funded institutions have the ability publish openly with ease, while those with lower budgets are pushed toward closed infrastructures, or away from high-profile journals altogether. Thus, the result might be a research record that seems inclusive, yet the ability to contribute to it stays unequal. 

While article charges are only the visible part of the bill, a big part of the real cost remains unseen and unpaid. This part includes the time researchers spend as authors, reviewers and editors. On the other hand, privately owned research evaluation systems mean that institutions need to pay to access records of their own work. In this context, Fraser's idea of redistribution explains the need for publishing models that charge neither readers nor authors, and the shared infrastructure that keeps those models viable. 

Tools you can adapt, not just license

The same logic applies to the systems underneath research including indexes, identifiers and metadata that decide what can be found and what gets counted.

Meagher explains how African universities, built on imported models, became powerful centres of original research in the 1960s and 1970s. Nevertheless, when their priorities were set by outside funders, the universities lost ground. In her account, owning your institutions is important to maintain autonomy while producing knowledge. 

Research infrastructure works in a similar manner. A proprietary database can be licensed, but it cannot be inspected, adapted, or governed by the communities whose work it describes. Open-source software and openly licensed metadata, on the contrary, are shared tools that any institution, region or country can use, extend and build on. 

Where OpenAIRE stands

OpenAIRE is built on these principles. We are a non-profit, member-based organisation, governed by the institutions we serve and committed to science as a public good.

The OpenAIRE Graph, one of the world's largest open scholarly knowledge graphs, links publications, data, software, researchers, organisations and funding, and it is open for anyone to reuse. Our network of National Open Access Desks anchors Open Science in national contexts, instead of imposing a one-size-fits-all model.

We recently signed a Memorandum of Understanding with Free Knowledge Africa which builds on the commitment that "communities have a voice in shaping the infrastructures that support them".

None of this solves inequality in research on its own but it puts the tools in common hands, and that is where redistribution starts.

Repurposing as a practice

Making research visible is the first step. Making its infrastructure shared, adaptable and collectively governed is the next one. That is the work we want to keep doing with our members and partners, in Europe and beyond.  

Reference

Meagher, K. (2025). Decolonizing Development Studies: Rejecting or Repurposing the Master's Tools? The European Journal of Development Research, 37, 407–420. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41287-024-00686-1

×
Stay Informed

When you subscribe to the blog, we will send you an e-mail when there are new updates on the site so you wouldn't miss them.

From Federated Catalogues to Shared Research Servi...
Understanding Science, Technology and Innovation i...