Hybrid healthcare governance for improvement? combining top-down and bottom-up approaches to public sector regulation

McDermott, Aoife Mary; Hamel, Lauren; Steel, David; Flood, Patrick C.; McKee, Lorna (2015)
Wiley Blackwell
JObject, JObject
Improving healthcare governance is an enduring challenge for policy-makers. We consider two national healthcare regulators adopting novel ‘hybrid’ regulatory control strategies in pursuit of improvement. Hybrids combine elements usually found separately. Scotland and Ireland’s regulators combine: (1) top-down formal regulatory mechanisms deterring breaches of protocol and enacting penalties where they occur (e.g. standard-setting, monitoring, accountability); and (2) bottom-up capacity building and persuasive encouragement of adherence to guidance by professional self-determination, implementation and improvement support (e.g. training, stimulating interventions). We identify socio-historical contextual factors constraining and enabling regulatory hybridity, whether and how it can be recreated, and circumstances when the approaches might be delivered separately. Using our findings, we develop a goal-oriented governance framework illustrating distinct, yet complementary, national and local organizational roles: (1) ensuring the adoption and implementation of best-practice, (2) enabling and (3) empowering staff to adapt and add to national mandates and (4) embedding cultures of improvement.

Download from

Cite this article




Cookies make it easier for us to provide you with our services. With the usage of our services you permit us to use cookies.
More information Ok