Remember Me
Or use your Academic/Social account:


Or use your Academic/Social account:


You have just completed your registration at OpenAire.

Before you can login to the site, you will need to activate your account. An e-mail will be sent to you with the proper instructions.


Please note that this site is currently undergoing Beta testing.
Any new content you create is not guaranteed to be present to the final version of the site upon release.

Thank you for your patience,
OpenAire Dev Team.

Close This Message


Verify Password:
Verify E-mail:
*All Fields Are Required.
Please Verify You Are Human:
fbtwitterlinkedinvimeoflicker grey 14rssslideshare1
Heffernan, Michael (2014)
Publisher: Wiley
Languages: English
Types: Article
This essay considers the politics and patronage of geography in early-modern France. It examines how the Paris Academy of Sciences, widely acknowledged as the 18th century’s pre-eminent scientific society, came to recognise geography as an independent science in 1730, a century before the establishment of the first geographical societies. Although the Academy was centrally concerned with cartography from its inception in 1666, it initially afforded no official status to geography, which was viewed either as a specialised form of historical inquiry or as a minor component within the hegemonic science of astronomy. The rise of Newtonian mathematics and the associated controversy about the shape of the earth challenged the Academy’s epistemological foundations and prompted a debate about the educational and political significance of geography as a scientific practice. The death in 1726 of Guillaume Delisle, a prominent Academy astronomer-cartographer and a popular geography tutor to the young Louis XV, led to a spirited campaign to elect Philippe Buache, Delisle’s prot�eg�e, to a new Academy position as a geographer rather than an astronomer. The campaign emphasised the social and political utility of geography, though the Academy’s decision to recognise this new and distinctively modern science was ultimately facilitated by traditional networks of patronage within the French Royal Court.
  • The results below are discovered through our pilot algorithms. Let us know how we are doing!

    • Antoine M 1989 Louis XV Fayard, Paris
    • Appleby J 2001 Mapping Russia: Farquharson, Delisle and the Royal Society Notes & Records of the Royal Society 52 191- 204
    • Biagioli M 1996 Etiquette, interdependence, and sociability in seventeenth-century science Critical Inquiry 22 193-238
    • Boutier J, Passeron J-C and Revel J eds 2006 Qu'est-ce qu'une discipline? Editions de l'EHESS, Paris
    • Brian E 1994 La mesure de l'etat: administrateurs et geometres au XVIIIe siecle Albin Michel, Paris
    • Brian E and Demeulenaere-Douyere C eds 1996 Histoire et memoire de l'Academie des Sciences: guide de recherches Editions Tec & Doc, Paris
    • Briggs R 1991 The Academie Royale des Sciences and the pursuit of utility Past and Present 131 38-88
    • Brioist P 2007 The Royal Society and the Academie des Sciences in the first half of the eighteenth century in Charle C, Vincent J and Winter J eds Anglo-French attitudes: comparisons and transfers between English and French intellectuals since the eighteenth century Manchester University Press, Manchester 63-77
    • Broc N 1969 Les montagnes vues par les geographes et les naturalistes de langue francaise au XVIIIe siecle Bibliotheque Nationale, Paris
    • Broc N 1970 Une affaire de plagiat cartographique sous Louis XIV: le proces Delisle-Nolin Revue d'Histoire des Sciences et de leurs Applications 23 141-53
    • Broc N 1971 Un geographe dans son siecle: Philippe Buache (1700-1773) Dix-huitieme Siecle 3 223-35
    • Broc N 1974 La geographie des philosophes: geographes et voyageurs francais au XVIIIe siecle Editions Ophrys, Paris
    • Burke P 1994 The fabrication of Louis XIV Yale University Press, New Haven CT
    • Chabin A-M 1996 Moscovie ou Russie? Regard de JosephNicolas Delisle et des savants francais sur les Etats de Pierre le Grand Dix-huitieme Siecle 28 43-56
    • Cohen A 1981 Music at the French Royal Academy of Sciences: a study in the evolution of musical thought Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ
    • Cormack L 1997 Charting an empire: geography in the English universities, 1580-1620 University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Crosland M 1992 Science under control: the French Academy of Sciences, 1795-1914 Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
    • Darnton R 2010 Poetry and the police: communications networks in eighteenth-century Paris Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA
    • Daston L 1991 Marvelous facts and miraculous evidence in early modern Europe Critical Inquiry 18 93-124
    • Daston L 1992 Classifications of knowledge in the age of Louis XIV in Rubin D L ed Sun King: the ascendancy of French culture during the reign of Louis XIV Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington DC 207-20
    • Daston L 1998 The nature of nature in early modern Europe Configurations 6 149-72
    • Daston L 2004 Attention and the values of nature in the Enlightenment in Daston L and Vidal F eds The moral authority of nature Chicago University Press, Chicago IL 100-26
    • Daston L and Park K 1998 Wonders and the order of nature, 1150-1750 Zone Books, New York
    • Dawson N-M 2000 L'Atelier Delisle: l'Amerique du Nord sur la table a dessin Sillery, Quebec
    • Debarbieux B 2009 Mountains: between pure reason and embodied experience: Philippe Buache and Alexander von Humboldt in Cosgrove D and della Dora V eds High places: cultural geographies of mountains, ice and science I B Tauris, London 87-104
    • DeJean J 1997 Ancients against moderns: culture wars and the making of a fin de siecle University Press of Chicago, Chicago IL
    • Demeulenaere-Douyere C and Brian E eds 2002 Reglement, usages et science dans la France de l'absolutisme a l'occasion du troisieme centenaire du reglement instituant l'Academie Royale des Sciences (26 janvier 1699) Editions Tec & Doc, Paris
    • Demeulenaere-Douyere C and Sturdy D eds 2008 L'Enqu^ete du Regent, 1716-1718: sciences, techniques et politique dans la France pre-industrielle Brepols, Turnhout
    • Doublet C 1910 Une famille d'astronomes et de geographes Cledes, Bordeaux
    • Doyle W 1996 Venality: the sale of offices in eighteenth-century France Clarendon Press, Oxford
    • Drapeyron L 1888 Les deux Buache et l'éducation geographique de trois rois de France (Louis XVI, Louis XVIII, Charles X) avec documents inedits Delagrave, Paris
    • Elliott P 2010 Enlightenment, modernity and science: geographies of scientific culture and improvement in Georgian England I B Tauris, London
    • Foucault M 1966 Les mots et les choses: une archeologie des sciences humaines Gallimard, Paris
    • Foucault M 1969 L'archeologie du savoir Gallimard, Paris
    • Foucault M 1980 Power/knowledge: selected interviews and other writings, 1972-1977 Gordon C ed Pantheon Press, New York
    • Fumaroli M 2001 La querelle des anciens et des modernes Gallimard, Paris
    • Gillispie C C 1980 Science and polity in France at the end of the Old Regime Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ
    • Gillispie C C 2004 Science and polity in France: the Revolutionary and Napoleonic years Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ
    • Glacken C 1973 Traces on the Rhodian shore: nature and culture in Western thought from ancient times to the end of the eighteenth century University of California Press, Berkeley CA
    • Godlewska A 1999 Geography unbound: French geographic science from Cassini to Humboldt University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Greenberg J L 1984 Degrees of longitude and the earth's shape: the diffusion of a scientific idea in Paris in the 1730s Annals of Science 41 151-8
    • Greenberg J L 1995 The problem of the earth's shape from Newton to Clairaut: the rise of mathematical science in eighteenth-century Paris and the fall of 'normal' science Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
    • Gross A, Harmon J and Reidy M 2002 Communicating science: the scientific article from the 17th century to the present Oxford University Press, Oxford
    • Hahn R 1971 The anatomy of a scientific institution: the Paris Academy of Sciences, 1666-1830 University of California Press, Berkeley CA
    • Halleux R, McClellan J, Berariu D and Xhayet G 2001 Les publications de l'Academie Royale des Sciences de Paris (1666-1793) Tome I: Description bibliographique Brepols, Turnhout
    • Heffernan M 2011 Courtly geography: nature, authority and civility in early eighteenth-century France in Daniels S, DeLyser D, Entrikin J N and Richardson D eds Envisioning landscapes, making worlds: geography and the humanities Routledge, London 94-105
    • Henry J 2005 National styles in science: a possible factor in the Scientific Revolution in Livingstone D N and Withers C W J eds Geography and revolution University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL 43-74
    • Hirschfield J M 1981 [1957] The Academie Royale des Sciences, 1666-1683: inauguration and initial problems of method Arno Press, New York
    • Holmes F L 2003 Chemistry in the Academie Royale des Sciences Historical Studies in the Physical and Biological Sciences 34 41-68
    • Jacob M 2006 Strangers nowhere in the world: the rise of cosmopolitanism in early modern Europe University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia PA
    • Kish G 1976 Early thematic mapping: the work of Philippe Buache Imago Mundi 38 129-36
    • Konvitz J 1987 Cartography in France 1660-1848: science, engineering, and statecraft University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Laboulais I 2004 Le systeme de Buache, une 'nouvelle facon de considerer notre globe' et de combler les blancs de la carte in Laboulais I ed. Combler les blancs de la carte: modalite et enjeux de la construction des savoirs geographiques (XVIIIe.-XXe. siecle) Presses Universitaires de Strasbourg, Strasbourg 93-115
    • Laboulais I 2010 Inventorier et cartographier les ressources minerales en France des annees 1740 aux annees 1830 in Besse J-M, Blais H and Surun I eds Naissances de la geographie moderne (1760-1860): lieux, pratiques et formation des savoirs de l'espace ENS Editions, Lyons 155-93
    • Lagarde L 1985 Philippe Buache, 1700-1773 Geographers: BioBibliographical Studies 9 21-7
    • Lagarde L 1989 Le passage de nord-ouest et la Mer de l'Ouest dans la cartographie francaise du 18e. siecle: contribution a l'etude de l'oeuvre de Delisle et Buache Imago Mundi 41 19- 43
    • Lagarde L 1998 Philippe Buache: cartographe ou geographe? in Lecoq D and Chambard A eds Terre a decouvrir, terres a parcourir: exploration et connaissance du monde au XIIeXIXe siecles L'Harmattan, Paris 147-66
    • Livingstone D N 2003 Putting science in its place: geographies of scientific knowledge University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Livingstone D N and Withers C W J eds 1999 Geography and Enlightenment University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Lowenthal D 1985 The past is a foreign country Cambridge University Press, Cambridge IL
    • Lux D S 1989 Patronage and royal science in seventeenth-century France: the Academie de Physique in Caen Cornell University Press, Ithaca NY
    • Lux D S 1990 Colbert's plan for the Grande Academie: royal policy toward science, 1663-67 Seventeenth-Century French Studies 12 177-88
    • Lux D S and Cook H J 1998 Closed circles and open networks? Communicating at a distance during the Scientific Revolution History of Science 36 179-211
    • Maindron E 1888 L'Academie des sciences Alcan, Paris
    • Marsak L M 1959 Bernard de Fontenelle: the idea of science in the French Enlightenment Transactions of the American Philosophical Society NS 49 1-63
    • Mayhew R J 2000 Enlightenment geography: the political languages of British geography 1650-1850 Palgrave, London
    • Mayhew R J 2004 Geography books and the character of Georgian politics in Ogborn M and Withers C W J eds Georgian geographies: essays in space, place and landscape in the eighteenth century Manchester University Press, Manchester 192-211
    • Mayhew R J 2005 Mapping science's imagined community: geography as a Republic of Letters, 1600-1800 British Journal for the History of Science 38 73-92
    • Mayhew R J 2010 Geography as the eye of Enlightenment historiography Modern Intellectual History 7 611-27
    • McClellan J E 1981 The Academie Royale des Sciences, 1699- 1793: a statistical portrait Isis 72 541-67
    • McClellan J E 1985 Science reorganized: scientific societies in the eighteenth century Columbia University Press, New York
    • McClellan J E 2001 The memoires of the Academie Royale des Sciences, 1699-1790: a statistical overview in Halleux R,
    • Safier N 2008 Measuring the new world: Enlightenment science and South America University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Salomon-Bayet C 1978 L'institution de la science et l'experience du vivant: methode et experience a l'Academie Royale des Sciences, 1666-1793 Flammarion, Paris
    • Schiebinger L 1988 Feminine icons: the face of early-modern science Critical Inquiry 14 661-91
    • Schulze L 1985 The Russification of the St Petersburg Academy of Sciences and Arts in the eighteenth century British Journal for the History of Science 18 305-35
    • Shank J B 2008 The Newton wars and the beginning of the French Enlightenment University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Smith C T 1969 The drainage basin as an historical basis for human activity in Chorley R J ed Water, earth and man: a synthesis of hydrology, geomorphology and socio-economic geography Methuen, London 101-10
    • Soll J 2009 The information master: Jean-Baptiste Colbert's secret state intelligence system University of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor MI
    • Sorrenson R 1996 Towards a history of the Royal Society in the eighteenth century Notes & Records of the Royal Society 50 29-46
    • Spary E 2000 Utopia's garden: French natural history from Old Regime to Revolution University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Sponberg Pedley M 1992 Bel et Utile: The Work of the Robert de Vaugondy Family of Mapmakers The Map Collector, Tring
    • Sponberg Pedley M 2005 The commerce of cartography: making and marketing maps in eighteenth-century France and England University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Stroup A 1987 Royal funding of the Parisian Academie Royale des Sciences during the 1690s Philadelphia: Transactions of the American Philosophical Society vol 77
    • Stroup A 1990 A company of scientists: botany, patronage and community at the seventeenth-century Parisian Royal Academy of Sciences University of California Press, Berkeley CA
    • Stroup A 1993 Science, politique et conscience aux debuts de l'Academie royale des sciences Revue de synthese 114 423-53
    • Sturdy D J 1995 Science and social status: the members of the Academie des Sciences, 1666-1750 The Boydell Press, Woodbridge
    • Terrall M 1995 Gendered spaces, gendered audiences: inside and outside the Paris Academy of Sciences Configurations 3 207-32
    • Terrall M 2002 The man who flattened the earth: Maupertuis and the sciences of the Enlightenment University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Tits-Dieuaide M-J 1998 Les savants, le societe et l'Etat: a propos du 'renouvellement' de l'Academie royale des sciences (1699) Journal des Savants 1 79-114
    • Williams G 2002 Voyages of delusion: the Northwest Passage in the Age of Reason HarperCollins, London
    • Withers C W J 1996 Encyclopaedism, modernism and the classification of geographical knowledge Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 21 275-98
    • Withers C W J 2005 Geography, science and the Scientific Revolution in Livingstone D N and Withers C W J eds Geography and revolution University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL 75-105
    • Withers C W J 2006 Eighteenth-century geography: texts, practices, sites Progress in Human Geography 30 711-29
    • Withers C W J 2007 Placing the Enlightenment: thinking geographically about the age of reason University of Chicago Press, Chicago IL
    • Withers C W J and Mayhew R J 2002 Rethinking 'disciplinary' history: geography in British universities, c. 1580-1887 Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers NS 27 11-29
    • Yates F A 1947 The French Academies of the sixteenth century Warburg Institute, London
    • Yeo R 2003 Classifying the sciences in Porter R ed The Cambridge history of science. Vol. 4: The eighteenth century Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 239-66
  • No related research data.
  • No similar publications.

Share - Bookmark

Cite this article