OpenAIRE is about to release its new face with lots of new content and services.
During September, you may notice downtime in services, while some functionalities (e.g. user registration, login, validation, claiming) will be temporarily disabled.
We apologize for the inconvenience, please stay tuned!
For further information please contact helpdesk[at]

fbtwitterlinkedinvimeoflicker grey 14rssslideshare1
Humle, Tatyana; Newton-Fisher, Nicholas E. (2013)
Publisher: Berghahn Books
Languages: English
Types: Part of book or chapter of book
Subjects: GN, QL
The attribution of culture to non-human animals has been controversial and continues to fuel much heated debate, much of which hinges on how culture is defined. We illustrate how definitions have become less human-centric as observations from wild primates have led to a new discipline – cultural primatology – and challenged the idea of culture as uniquely human. Although cultural primatology has it roots in field studies of wild primates, the weight of captive studies across a variety of species has resulted in a comparative view of culture which emphasises the mechanism of transmission. We argue that, while this has broadened the species and behaviours that have been considered ‘cultural’, it weakens the usefulness of comparative studies in understanding the evolutionary origins of human culture. We prefer a definition that centres on the concept of culture as an array of behaviour patterns across multiple domains that vary between groups or populations due to differing histories of social transmission. We argue for the necessity of field studies of wild primates in the comparative study of culture, providing examples of how such studies allow both the identification of cultures across non-human primate social groups and the mechanisms by which behaviours are transmitted both within and between groups. Such studies are essential for an ecologically valid understanding of culture, and to investigate how social dynamics, ecology and demographics shape culture and the diffusion and dissemination of socially learned behaviours.
  • The results below are discovered through our pilot algorithms. Let us know how we are doing!

    • arnhart, l. 1994. 'the Darwinian Biology of aristotle's Politi cal animals', American Journal of Political Science 38(2): 464-85.
    • Bastian, m.l, n. Zweifel, e.r. vogel, s.a. Wich and C.P. van schai k. 2010.
    • 'Diet traditions in Wild orangutans', American Journal of Physical Anthropology 143(2): 175-87.
    • Biro, D., n. inoue-nakamura, r. tonooka, G. Yamakoshi, C. sousa and t. matsuzawa. 2003. 'Cultural innovation and transmission of tool-use in Wild Chimpanzees: evidence from field experieme nts, Animal Cognition 6: 213-23.
    • .C. sousa and t. matsuzawa. 2006. 'ontogeny and Cultural Propagation of tool use by Wild Chimpanzees at Bossou, Guinea: Case studies in nut Cracking and leaf folding', in t. matsuzaw a, m. tomonaga and m. tanaka (eds), Cognitive Development in Chimpanzees. new York: springer, pp. 476-508.
    • Boesch, C. 1991. 'teaching among Wild Chimpanzees', Animal Behaviour 41: 530-32.
    • and h. Boesch. 1983. 'optimisation of nut Cracking with natu ral hammers by Wild Chimpanzees', Behaviour 83(3-4): 265-86.
    • Brewer, s.m. and W.C. mcGrew. 1990. 'Chimpanzee use of a tool-s et to Get honey', Folia Primatologica 54: 100-4.
    • Caldwell, C.a., and a.e. millen. 2009. 'social learning mech anisms and Cumulative Cultural evolution: is imitation necessary?', Psychological Science 20(12): 1478-83.
    • and a.e. millen. 2010. 'human Cumulative Culture in the laboratory: effects of (micro) Population size', Learning and Behavior 38(3): 310-18.
    • Carvalho, s., D. Biro, W.C. mcGrew and t. matsuzawa. 2009. 't ool-composite reuse in Wild Chimpanzees ( Pan troglodytes): archaeologically invisible steps in the technological evolution of early hominin s?, Animal Cognition 12: s103-14.
    • .e. Cunha, C. sousa and t. matsuzawa. 2008. 'Chaines operatoi res and resource-exploitation strategies in Chimpanzee ( Pan troglodytes) nut Cracking', Journal of Human Evolution 55(1): 148-63.
    • Collard, m. 2010. 'integrating anthropological Genetics wit h Cultural anthropology and archaeology: new opportunities', Journal of Anthropological Science 88: 239-42.
    • Darwin, C. 1871. The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex. london: John murray.
    • Dindo, m., B. thierry and a. Whiten. 2008. 'social Diffusion of n ovel foraging methods in Brown Capuchin monkeys ( Cebus apella)', Proceedings of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 275(1631): 187-93.
    • fox, e.a., C.P. van schaik, a. sitompul and D.n. Wright. 2004. 'intra- and interpopulational Differences in orangutan ( Pongo pygmaeus) activity and Diet: implications for the invention of tool use', American Journal of Physical Anthropology 125(2): 162-74.
    • fragaszy, D.m., r. Greenberg, e. visalberghi, e.B. ottoni, P . izar and Q. liu. 2010. 'how Wild Bearded Capuchin monkeys select stones and nuts to minimize the number of strikes per nut Cracked', Animal Behaviour 80(2): 205-14.
    • and s.e. Perry. 2003. The Biology of Traditions: Models and Evidence. Cambridge university Press.
    • Galef, B.G. 1992. 'the Question of animal Culture', Human Nature 3: 157-78.
    • Goodall, J. 1973. 'Cultural elements in a Chimpanzee Community', in e.W. menzel (ed.), Precultural Primate Behaviour. Basel: Karger. pp. 195-249.
    • Gruber, t., m.n. muller, P. strimling, r. Wrangham and K. Zuber buhler. 2009. 'Wild Chimpanzees rely on Cultural Knowledge to solve an experimental honey acquisition task', Current Biology 19(21): 1806-10.
    • haslam, m., a. hernandez-aguilar, v. ling, s. Carvalho, i. de la torre, a. Destefano, a. Du, B. hardy, J. harris, l. marchant et al. 2009 . 'Primate archaeology', Nature 460: 339-44.
    • helfman, G.s. and e.t. schultz. 1984. 'social tradition of Behav ioural traditions in a Coral reef fish', Animal Behaviour 32: 379-84.
    • hirata, s., K. Watanabe, m. Kawai and t. matsuzawa. 2001. '“sw eet-potato Washing” revisited', in t. matsuzawa (ed.), Primate Origins of Human Cognition and Behavior. tokyo: springer-verlag, pp. 487-508.
    • hohmann, G. and B. fruth. 2003. 'Culture in Bonobos? Between-s pecies and Within-species variation in Behavior', Current Anthropology 44: 563-71.
    • hopper, l.m., a. spiteri, s.P. lambeth, s.J. schapiro, v. hor ner and a. Whiten. 2007. 'experimental studies of traditions and underlyi ng transmission Processes in Chimpanzees', Animal Behaviour 73: 1021-32.
    • hoppitt, W., n.J. Boogert, and K.n. laland. 2010. 'Detectin g social transmission in networks', Journal of Theoretical Biology 263(4): 544-55.
    • horner, v. 2010. 'the Cultural mind of Chimpanzees: how socia l tolerance can shape the transmission of Culture', in e.v. lonsdorf, s.r. ross and t. matsuzawa (eds), The Mind of the Chimpanzee. Chicago and london: university of Chicago Press, pp. 101-15.
    • .a. Whiten, e. flynn and f.B.m. de Waal. 2006. 'faithful repl ication of foraging techniques along Cultural transmission Chains by Chimpanzees and Children', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 103(37): 13878-83.
    • humle, t. 2010. 'how are army ants shedding new light on Culture in Chimpanzees', in e.v. lonsdorf, s.r. ross and t. matsuzawa (eds), The Mind of Chimpanzees. Chicago and london: university of Chicago Press, pp. 116-25.
    • and t. matsuzawa. 2001. 'Behavioural Diversity among the W ild Chimpanzee Populations of Bossou and neighbouring areas, Guinea and Cote d'ivoire, West africa', Folia Primatologica 72: 57-68.
    • and t. matsuzawa. 2002. 'ant Dipping among the Chimpanzees of Bossou, Guinea, and Comparisons with other sites', American Journal of Primatology 58: 133-48.
    • and t. matsuzawa. 2004. 'oil Palm use by adjacent Communit ies of Chimpanzees at Bossou and nimba mountains, West africa', International Journal of Primatology 25: 551-81.
    • and C.t. snowdon. 2008. 'socially Biased learning in the acquisition of a Complex foraging task in Juvenile Cottontop tamarins ( Saguinus oedipus)', Animal Behavaviour 75: 267-77.
    • .C.t. snowdon and t. matsuzawa. 2009. 'social inluences on an tdipping acquisition in the Wild Chimpanzees ( Pan troglodytes verus) of Bossou, Guinea, West africa', Animal Cognition 12: s37-s48.
    • ingold, t. 2001. 'the use and abuse of ethnography', Behavioral and Brain Science 24: 337.
    • inoue-nakamura, n. and t. matsuzawa. 1997. 'Development of s tone tool use by Wild Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes)', Journal of Comparative Psychology 111: 159-73.
    • Jaeggi, a.v., l.P. Dunkel, m.a. van noordwijk, s.a. Wich, a.a. l. sura and C.P. van schaik. 2010. 'social learning of Diet and foraging sk ills by Wild immature Bornean orangutans: implications for Cultu re, American Journal of Primatology 72: 62-71.
    • .l. Dunkel and C.P. van schaik. 2007. 'the role of social learni ng in the acquisition of foraging skills in Wild Bornean orang-ut ans (Pongo pygmaeus)', American Journal of Physical Anthropology suppl. 44: 135.
    • Kant, i. 1786. 'mutmasslicher anfang der menschengeschicht e', Berlinische Monatschrift 176: 1-27.
    • Kawamura, s. 1959. 'the Process of sub-cultural Propagation am ong Japanese macaques, Primates 2: 43-60.
    • Kendal, r.l. 2008. 'animal “Culture Wars”', The Psychologist 21: 312-15.
    • Koops, K., W.C. mcGrew and t. matsuzawa. 2008. Nut-cracking and the Chimpanzees of the Nimba Mountains, Guinea, West Africa: An Experimental Approach to the Study of Ape Technology, international Primatological society. edinburgh: Primate eye-PsGB, abst #395.
    • Kroeber, a.l. 1928. 'sub-human Culture Beginnings', Quaterly Review of Biology 3: 325-42.
    • and C. Kluckhohn. 1952. 'Culture: a Critical review of Concep ts and Deinitions', Papers of the Peabody Museum of American Archaeology and Ethnology 47: 1-223.
    • Kummer, h. 1971. Primate Societies: Group Techniques of Ecological Adaptation. Chicago: aldine.
    • laland, K.n. and W. hoppitt. 2003. 'Do animals have Culture? ', Evolutionary Anthropology 12: 150-59.
    • and v.m. Janik. 2006. 'the animal Cultures Debate', Trends In Ecology and Evolution 21: 542-47.
    • and J.r. Kendal. 2003. 'What the models say about animal so cial learning', in D.m. fragaszy and s. Perry (eds), The Biology of Traditions: Models and Evidence. Cambridge: Cambridge university Press, pp. 33-55.
    • leca, J.B., n. Gunst and m.a. huffman. 2007. 'Japanese macaque Cultures: inter- and intra-troop Behavioural variability of stone handl ing Patterns across 10 troops', Behaviour 144: 251-81.
    • lind, J. and P. lindenfors. 2010. 'the number of Cultural trai ts is Correlated with female Group size but not with male Group size in Chimpanzee Communities', PLoS One 5: e9241.
    • lonsdorf, e.v. 2006. 'What is the role of mothers in the acquisiti on of termite-ishing Behaviors in Wild Chimpanzees ( Pan troglodytes schweinfurthii)?', Animal Cognition 9(1): 36-46.
    • and K.e. Bonnie. 2010. 'opportunities and Constraints when studying social learning: Developmental approaches and so cial factors'. Learning and Behavior 38(3): 195-205.
    • lycett, s.J. 2010. 'the importance of history in Deinitions of C ulture: implications from Phylogenetic approaches to the study of soc ial learning in Chimpanzees', Learning and Behavior 38(3): 252-64.
    • .2011. '“most Beautiful and most Wonderful”: those endless stone tool forms', Journal of Evolutionary Psychology 9(2): 143-71.
    • .m. Collard and W.C. mcGrew. 2007. 'Phylogenetic analyses of Behavior support existence of Culture among Wild Chimpanzees ', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 104(45): 17588-92.
    • .m. Collard and W.C. mcGrew. 2010. 'are Behavioral Differenc es among Wild Chimpanzee Communities Genetic or Cultural? an assessment using tool-use Data and Phylogenetic methods', American Journal of Physical Anthropology 142(3): 461-67.
    • mannu, m. and e.B. ottoni. 2009. 'the enhanced tool-kit of two Gr oups of Wild Bearded Capuchin monkeys in the Caatinga: tool making, associative use and secondary tools', American Journal of Primatology 71(3): 242-51.
    • matsuzawa, t. 1994. 'field experiments on use of stone tools by Ch impanzees in the Wild', in r.W. Wrangham, W.C. mcGrew, f.B.m. de Waal and P.G. heltne (eds), Chimpanzee Cultures. Cambridge: harvard university Press, pp. 351-70.
    • .D. Biro, t. humle, n. inoue-nakamura, r. tonooka, G. Yamakoshi and t. matsuzawa. 2001. 'emergence of Culture in Wild Chimpanzees: education by master-apprenticeship', in t . matsuzawa (ed.), Primate Origins of Human Cognition and Behavior. tokyo: springer-verlag, pp. 557-74.
    • .t. humle and Y. sugiyama (eds). 2011. The Chimpanzees of Bossou and Nimba. tokyo: springer-verlag.
    • and W.C. mcGrew. 2008. 'Kinji imanishi and 60 years of Japanese Primatology', Current Biology 18(14): r587-r591.
    • mcGrew, W.C. 1992. Chimpanzee Material Culture: Implications for Human Evolution. Cambridge: Cambridge university Press.
    • 2003. 'ten Dispatches from the Chimpanzee Culture Wars', in f.B.m. de Waal and P.l. tyack (eds), Animal Social Complexity Intelligence, Culture and Individualized Societies. Cambridge: havard university Press, pp. 419-39.
    • .r.m. ham, l.J.t. White, C.e.G. tutin and m. fernandez. 1997 . 'Why Don't Chimpanzees in Gabon Crack nuts? International Journal of Primatology 18: 353-74.
    • and C.e.G. tutin. 1978. 'evidence for a social Custom in Wil d Chimpanzees?', Man 13(2): 234-51.
    • mercader, J., h. Barton, J. Gillespie, J. harris, s. Kuhn, r. tyler and C. Boesch. 2007. '4,300-year-old Chimpanzee sites and the orig ins of Percussive stone technology', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 104(9): 3043-48.
    • .m. Panger and C. Boesch. 2002. 'excavation of a Chimpanzee stone tool site in the african rainforest', Science 296: 1452-55.
    • mobius, Y., C. Boesch, K. Koops, t. matsuzawa and t. humle. 200 8. 'Cultural Differences in army ant Predation by West african Chimpanzees ? a Comparative study of microecological variables', Animal Behaviour 76: 37-45.
    • nakamura m. and s. uehara. 2004. 'Proximate factors of two typ es of Grooming-hand-clasp in mahale Chimpanzees: implication for Chimpanzee social Custom', Current Anthropology 45(1):108-14.
    • ottoni, e.B. and P. izar. 2008. 'Capuchin monkey tool use: overv iew and implications', Evolutionary Anthropology 17(4): 171-78.
    • Panger, m.a., s. Perry, l. rose, J. Gros-louis, e. vogel, K.C. mackinnon and m. Baker. 2002. Cross-site Differences in foraging Behav ior of White-faced Capuchins (Cebus capucinus), American Journal of Physical Anthropology 119(1): 52-66.
    • Perry, s. 2009. 'Conformism in the food Processing techniques of Whitefaced Capuchin monkeys (Cebus capucinus)', Animal Cognition 12(5): 705-16.
    • .m. Baker, l. fedigan, J. Gros-louis, K. Jack, K.C. macKinnon, J.h. manson, m. Panger, K. Pyle and l. rose. 2003. 'social Conventions in Wild White-faced Capuchin monkeys - evidence for traditions in a neotropical Primate', Current Anthropology 44(2): 241-68.
    • sanz, C.m. and D.B. morgan. 2007. 'Chimpanzee tool technology i n the Goualougo triangle, republic of Congo', Journal of Human Evolution 52(4): 420-33.
    • and D.B. morgan. 2009. 'flexible and Persistent tool-using strategies in honey-gathering by Wild Chimpanzees', International Journal of Primatology 30(3): 411-27.
    • C. schoning and D.B. morgan. 2010. 'Chimpanzees Prey on army ants with specialized tool set', American Journal of Primatology 72(1): 17-24.
    • schaik, C.P. van, m. ancrenaz, G. Borgen, B. Galdikas, C.D. Knott, i. singleton, a. suzuki, s.s. utami and m. merrill. 2003a. 'orangutan Cult ures and the evolution of material Culture', Science 299(5603): 102-5.
    • e.a. fox, and l.t. fechtman. 2003b. 'individual variation i n the rate of use of tree-hole tools among Wild orangutans: imschoning, C., t. humle, Y. mobius and W.C. mcGrew. 2008.
    • 'the nature of Culture: technological variation in Chimpanzee Predation on army ants revisited', Journal of Human Evolution 55(1): 48-59.
    • sousa, C., D. Biro and t. matsuzawa. 2009. 'leaf-tool use for D rinking Water by Wild Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes): acquisition Patterns and handedness', Animal Cognition 12: s115-s125.
    • tomasello, m. 1999. The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition. Cambridge, ma: harvard university Press.
    • tonooka, r. 2001. 'leaf-folding Behavior for Drinking Water b y Wild Chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes verus) at Bossou, Guinea', Animal Cognition 4: 325-34.
    • tyler, e.B. 1871. Primitive Culture. london: murray.
    • visalberghi, e., D. fragaszy, e. ottoni, P. izar, m.G. de olive ira and f.r.D. andrade. 2007. 'Characteristics of hammer stones and anvils used by Wild Bearded Capuchin monkeys (Cebus libidinosus) to Crack open Palm nuts, American Journal of Physical Anthropology 132(3): 426-44.
    • voelkl, B and l. huber. 2000. 'true imitation in marmosets', Animal Behaviour 60: 195-202.
    • Waal, f.B.m. de. 1999. 'Cultural Primatology Comes of age', Nature 399: 635-36.
    • Watson, C.f.i. and C.a. Caldwell. 2009. 'understanding Behavi oral traditions in Primates: are Current experimental approaches too focused on food?', International Journal of Primatology 30(1): 143-67.
    • Whiten, a., J. Goodall, W.C. mcGrew, t. nishida, v. reynolds, Y. sugiyama, C.e. tutin, r.W. Wrangham and C. Boesch. 1999. 'Cultures in Chimpanzees', Nature 399(6737): 682-85.
    • .J. Goodall, W.C. mcGrew, t. nishida, v. reynolds, Y. sugiyam a, C.e. tutin, r.W. Wrangham and C. Boesch. 2001. 'Charting Cultural variation in Chimpanzees', Behaviour 138: 1481-516.
    • .v. horner, C.a. litchield and s. marshall-Pescini. 2004. ' how do apes ape?', Learning Behavaviour 32(1): 36-52.
    • Wich, s.a., s.s. utami atmoko, t. mitra setia and C.P. van scha ik (eds). 2009. Orangutans: Geographic Variation in Behavioral Ecology and Conservation. oxford: oxford university Press.
    • Wrangham, r.W., f.B.m. de Waal and W.C. mcGrew. 1994. 'the Ch allenge of Behavioral Diversity', in r.W. Wrangham, W.C. mcGrew, f.B.m . de Waal, P.G. heltne and l.a. marquardt (eds), Chimpanzee Cultures. Cambridge: harvard university Press, pp. 1-18.
    • Yamakoshi, G. and Y. sugiyama. 1995. 'Pestle-pounding Behav ior of Wild Chimpanzees at Bossou, Guinea: a newly observed tool-using Behavior', Primates 36(4): 489-500.
  • No related research data.
  • No similar publications.

Share - Bookmark

Download from

Cite this article

Cookies make it easier for us to provide you with our services. With the usage of our services you permit us to use cookies.
More information Ok