Remember Me
Or use your Academic/Social account:


Or use your Academic/Social account:


You have just completed your registration at OpenAire.

Before you can login to the site, you will need to activate your account. An e-mail will be sent to you with the proper instructions.


Please note that this site is currently undergoing Beta testing.
Any new content you create is not guaranteed to be present to the final version of the site upon release.

Thank you for your patience,
OpenAire Dev Team.

Close This Message


Verify Password:
Verify E-mail:
*All Fields Are Required.
Please Verify You Are Human:
fbtwitterlinkedinvimeoflicker grey 14rssslideshare1
Howard, Erica (2004)
Publisher: AB Academic Publishers
Languages: English
Types: Article
Legislation against racial discrimination makes, it is argued, a clcar statement against racism in all its forms and hence has symbolic value. This is expressed in\ud different ways, for example: a declaration of firm opposition to racism; the sending out or a clear political signal regarding the commitment to the fight against racism; a powerrul symbol and a statement of intent. This Article will argue that the European Union's Race directive had, at the time of its adoption, significant symbolic value because it made a clear and unequivical statement to\ud the Union's citizens, to its Member States and to the wider world, that the Union was committed to the elimination of racisrn and racial discrimination. The plans for enlargement of the European Union, with a number of States joining in 2004, added to the value of the statement: it signalled to these new Member States that the Union expects thcm to combat racism and racial or ethnic discrimination and to promote and adopt effective measures against such discr-imination in line with the Race Directive, as this has become part of the Acquis Comnunautaire, the body of law that: must be adopted by all States wishing to join. But does the Race Directive today, after the deadline for its implelnziltation has passed, still have any symbolic value?
  • The results below are discovered through our pilot algorithms. Let us know how we are doing!

    • Allott, A. (1980) f i e Liluits of' LCII,I)C, hapter G , 161-237. Butterworths; London.
    • Banton. M. (1994) Discr-i177ir~urionO, pei~University Press.
    • Barnard. C. (1999) Article 13: Through the Looking Glass of Union Citizenship. In Legai Issrte.r of tlze A1n~rerdi1~7iTtllr~earj, (O'Keeffc, D. and Twolney, P. (eds.) 375-95. Hart Publishjng; Oxrord.
    • Bell, M. and Waddington, L. (1996)The 1996 Intcrgoverl~i~ientaClonference and the Prospects ol' a Non-Discriininatiol Treaty Article. Ind~utrialLaii, .Jourrzctl 25. 4, 320,-36.
    • Bell, M. (1999) The New Article 13 EC: A Sound Basis for EU AntiDiscrimination Law? Mc1a.si1.icJ71Jotlr-~znJof E~.cropcm?rn7d Ca17~~~urniLiailiev, 6. 5-24.
    • Bell, M. (2000) Equality and Diversity: Anti-Discriminatioi Law after Amsterdam. In Sociul L U I 'aInd Policy ir? 017 evoll!i~~Qglrol~enrz Union (Shaw, J . (ed.), 157-71. Hart Publishing; Oxfol-d.
    • Bell, M. (2001) Meeting the Challenge? A Colnpalison between the EU Racial Equality Directiveand the Starting Line. In The Slarlirzg Line .and file Iilc~orporntiorrqf flze Racicrl Eqztnlily Dir.ccrii?ei?zlo1l7c I\mtiorzal Lnivs of (he Eli Aden?her. States crrzcl Acccssinjz Stales, Chopin, I. and Niessen, J. (eds.) 12-54. Belmont Press; Brussels/London.
    • Bell. M. (2002)a Combating Racism Through European Laws: A Comparison of the Racial Equality Directive and Protocol 12. In Cor7zbaling Rncic~alfzdEthnic Discrirnin.aliorz. T~rkingthe E~~ropeaLnegislative .4gench F~irther.( C l - ~ o ~ iIn. , and Niessen, J. (eds.), 7-34. Migration Policy Group and CRE;. Brussels] London.
    • Bell, M. (2002)b Arzti-Discri17zi~zc2tjonLaw clnd tlzr E~lropea~zUrziott. Oxford University Press.
    • Bindman, G. (1996) When will Europe Act Against Racism? Ezrrol~enizHzrr~~rzn Riglzts Law Revielv 2, 143-9.
    • Brown. C. (2002) The Race Directive: Towards Eq~li~litfyor ,211 the Peoples of Europe? Yearbook oj'E~~~opecLrmtzv, 21, 195-227.
    • Cl7arler of fimdcl~lzetztnl Rig11ts of the E~rropenrzUnion, [2OOO] OJ C 364:1.
    • Chopin, I. and Niessen, J. (eds.) (1998) Proposals ,for Leg.,uisl(~tivekfeasures to Conzbat Rocis~natzri to Proi~zoteEqual Rights in llie Europem7 Urziorz. CKE; London.
    • Chopin, I. (1999)~ Cutrlpaignir~g against Racisiiz and Xenoplzobia: Jronz Lqyislativc Perspecfil~eU? fin-opccmz Level. EL-AR. Brussels. The Ncw Starting Line l'roposal 1s annexed to this.
    • Cllopin, I. (1999)b The Starling Line Group: A Harmonized Approach to Fight Racism and -toPromote Equal Treatment, Ezlropean Joz~rrzalqj'Migration nrzrl LLlll: l, l l 1-29.
    • Chopin, I. and Niessen, J. (eds.) (2002) Combating Racial and Ethnic Discrimination. Taking the European Legislative Agenda further. Migration Policy Group and CRE: Brussels~London.
    • Claude Moraes MEP launches a 'Name and Shame' League Tablc of Failure to inlplelneilt new EU Race laws (2003) w~~w.claudemomes.i~ct~'article13transpose.htn11. This 'Name and Shame League Table' is available from the office of Cla~ldeMoraes, via the website above.
    • Corn~llissio ~fol r Racial Equality (2000) Article 13 Proposnls ji-ovr the Ezrropean Conzrnlssion for Co~nbati7zgDiscrinzi7zation, CRE); London. www.cre.gov.uk/ legaladv/artl3.htrnl
    • Coniinission Report COM (1999) 268 on the Implementation of the European Ycar ag,:linst Racism.
    • Communication COM (1999) 564 from the Commission to the Conncil, the European Parliament. the Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on certain Coinniunity Measures to combat Discrimination, 25/ 11/1999.
    • Coiicl~ldingObservations of the United Nations Colninittee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination on United Kingdom of Great Britain and 1Vorthern Ireland, CERDjC/63/CO/11, 10 December 2003 www.unhchr.ch/
    • Corlncil Decision 2000/750/EC of 27 November 2000 establishing a Community Action Progamme to combat Discriininatio~l(2001 to 2006), [2000] 0 J L 303:23-25.
    • Council Directive 76/207/EEC of 9 February 1976 on the Implementation of the Principle of Equal Treatment for Men and Women as regards Access to Employment, Vocational Training and Promotion, and Working Conditions, [l9761 OJ L 39:40--7.
    • Council Directive 2000/43/EC of 29 June 2000 inlplerneilting the Principle of Equai Treatment betweell Persons irrespective of Racial or Ethnic Origin, j2UOO] OJ L <1802-6.
    • Council Directive 2000/78/EC of 27 Novenlber 2000 establisl~inga gencral Framework ~ O I -Equal Treatment in E~nployme~alnt d Occupation, [2000] OJ L 303:16-72.
    • Council of Europe (1991) Firzal report of the Conznzz~riiij~Relcltions Project "Cor11177zmityarzd Ethrlic relafiorzs ilz Europe", MG-CR (91) 1 Final E. Strasbourg.
    • Curtin, D . and Gemts, X I . (1996) Race Discriininatioll and the European Union Anllo 1996: From Rhetoric to Legal Remedy? Netlzrrlur7ds Qz~nrterljlof I~zcl~zart Rights 14, 7 , 147-71.
    • Declaration and Action Program~nefrom the World Conference against Racism, RaciaI Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance, Durban, South Africa, 31,'s to 8/9/2001, AICONF. 189112 ww~~.unl~chl-.ch/11tn11/1-acism/ Declaration by the Council and tlic Representatives of the Governments of the Member States, meeting within the Council of 16 December 1997 on Respecting Diversity and Combating Racism and Xenopllobia, [l9981 OJ C ]:l.
    • Declaration of Inlent: 'Europe against Racism', signed at the lauizch of the European Year Against Racism, the Hague, 30 January 1997 by Wim Kok, President of the Council of the European Ui~ion.Jose Maria Gil-Robles GilDelgado, President of the Em-opean Parlia~ncntand Jaques Santer, President of the Eul-opean Coinmission.
    • Dinsdale, J. (1997) Combating Discrimination: A View from the Couilcil of Europe In Dcvclopn7ents Q1 Disn-i171ilzafior?L a ~ vin li-elulzd n17d E u r o ~ ~(eB. yrne, R. and Duncan, W. eds.) 9-32. Irish Centre Tor European Law, Trinity College Dublin.
    • Directive 7002/73/EC of the European Parliainent and of the Council of 23 September 2002 anlending Council Directive 76/707/EC on thc Implementation of the Principle of Equal Treatment for Men and Wornell as Regards Access to Bnployment, Vocational Training and Promotion, alzd Working Conditions, [2002] OJ L 269: 15-20.
    • Dummett. A. (1991j The Stai-tingLine: A Proposal for a Dralt Council Directive concerning the Elimination of Racial Discrimination. N e ~ vConz~nuriity20, 3. 530-8.
    • Duncan, W. (1997) Racism, Discrimination and Amendment of the European Coilllnunjty Treaty and the Treaty on European Union. In D~i~elopr7zel7tilsz Diso-ir7linutio~rLull. 1i7 Irelarzdurzd Europe. (Byrne, R. and Duncan, W. eds.) 43- 54. Irish Centrc for European Law, Trinity College Dublin.
    • ENAR (1003)a Press Release 7/07/7003, "Combating Racial Discrimination: Bad Score in Europe"? www.enar-eu,org/en/prcss/2003-07-07.shtml
    • ENAR (2003)b "Name and Shame" Public I-Jcaring Lacks Chairs, 8/07/2003, ~1ww.enar-eu.org/en/bmews/ii~dex.pl~p
    • ENAR (2003)~General Overview on the Transpositio~lof Council Directive 2000/43/EC implementing the Principle of Equal Treatment between Persons irrespective of their Racial or Ethnic origin, www.enar-eu.olrg/.enib, mews/docs/ gettxt =g ~ & d o =c 1P/03/l. 3370RAPID8ilg = EN&display =
    • Proposal COM (1985) 318 for a Council Resolution on the Fight against Racism and Xenophobia, [l9581 OJ C 2 14:32.
    • Proposal COM (1995) 653 for a Couilcil Decision designatills 1997 as European . . Year against Racism; [l9961 O J C Y9:7.
    • Proposal COM (1996) 615 for a Council Regulation (EC) establishing a European Monitoi-ing Centre for Racism and Xenophobia, [l9971 OJ C 7X:15.
    • Proposal COM (1.999) 565 for a Council Directive establishing a General Frameworlc for Equal Treatment in Employnlent and Education, 2511 111999.
    • Proposal COM (1999) 566 for a Council Directive implementing the Principle of Equal Treatmeilt between Pcrsons irrespective of Racial or Ethnic Origin, 251 11/1999.
    • Proposal COM (1999) 567 for a Council Decisiol~establishing a Community Action Progranlrne to combat Disci-imination (2001--2006), 2511 1/1999.
    • Proposal COM (2001) 127 for a Council Directive concerning the Status of Third Co~u~ltrNyatio~lalscvho are Long-Tenn Residents, [20111] OJ C 240E:79-87.
    • Proposal COM (7001) 664 for a Council. Framework Decision on Combating Racism and Xenophobia, 2511 1/2001.
    • R I ~ OoTj't~he Race Re1~rtion.rB o n d , 1966-1967, London, I-IMSO, 1967.
    • Resolution of the Council and the Representatives of the Governnlents of the Membcr Stales, meeting within thc Council of 29 May 1990 on the Fight against Racisin and Xenophobia: [l9901 OJ C 157:l-3.
    • Resolucioi~of the Co~mciland the Represeiltatives of the Govel-nments or the Menlber States, meeting in the Council of 23 July 1996 conccrniilg the European Year against Racism (1997), 119961 OJ C 237:l.
    • Resolution ofthe European Parliament on the Joint Declaration by the European Parliament, the Councill the Repi-esen~ativeso r the Member States meeting within the Council, and the Co~n~llissioangainst liacisn~and Xenophobia, [l9861 OJC 176163.
    • Resolution of the European Parliament on the Growing Number of Crimes Connected with Fascism, Racism and Xenophobia in the Conlmunity Countries, [l9871 OJ C 190:108.
    • Resolution of the European Parliament on the Joint Declal-ation against Racism and Xenophobia and an Action Programme by the Council of Ministers, [l9891 OJ C 69:40--3.
    • Resolution of the European Parliament on Racism, Xenophobia and AntiSernitisnl B4-26 1/94, [l9941 OJ C 323:1.54.
    • Resolution of the European Parliament on Racism, Xenopl~obiaand AntiSemitism, [ l 9951 OJ C 308:140.
    • Resolutio~lo r the European Parliament on Racism, Xenophobia and AntiSemitism and on f ~ ~ r t hSetreps to coinbat Racial Disclimination, [l9991 OJ C 98:45S.
    • Resolution on Measures to Combat Racism and Xenophobia, [l9901 OJ C175:178.
    • Resolution on Racisin and Xenophobia, [l99l] OJ C 280:146.
    • Resolutioll on Racism, Xenophobia and Anti-Semitism. [l9921 OJ C 30.51590.
    • Resolutio~lon Racism and Xenophobia, [l9931 OJ 342:19.
    • Resolutio~ron Racism, Xcnophobia and Anti-Semitism, C19951 OJ C 126:75.
    • Resolution on Racism, Xenopl~obiaand the Extreme Right, [l9971 0 J C 85: 150.
  • No related research data.
  • No similar publications.

Share - Bookmark

Cite this article